My Fight For A Career

Posted on:   Posted by:

Here’s one from the archives, AKA the old Sprout. Want to explore the archives? Dive right in, you’ll find over 5000 articles from 2007 to 2016.

Explore the archive

Update: My Fight For A Career was originally published on 11th December 2010 and is by P3.

This article was republished on the 5th January 2011, as the Welsh Government responded. Scroll down for their response!

Today I felt was time to actually get around to being a more active member of TheSprout.

I wanted to share my story on my battle with ‘The System.’

I am currently unemployed, a thing which can be highly stigmatised. Now to face this stigma is difficult in itself, without fighting to prosper yourself. I hope to become a social worker. Now for those not familiar with the requirements to be a social worker, you must now have a degree in social work. Now the obvious idea would be to go to college get a relevant qualification and apply for the degree.

Here comes the dilemma.

I am living independently, with bills and rent to pay, as it stands now I am supported by the government with Job Seekers Allowance (JSA). I have attended college once before, but I was made homeless and this caused me to have difficulty to continue studying, although I did attain an A-level in mathematics as I was a swat in high school.

When I was made homeless in January 2009 I was financially supported with Income Support (IS) due to my age and estrangement from family and in full-time education. When I return to college now I will be 19, this means the rules that allowed IS to support me last time are no longer relevant as you had to be under-19. The benefit I have to claim now is JSA because I am not in education right now.

But there is a grey area as the course is 16 hours a week, which is registered as part-time with the job centre if it is work, but the learning agreement would state the course is full time. If I am doing anything as full-time I am no longer entitled to JSA. I have to provide this learning agreement to the Job Centre as I am legally obliged to whilst claiming JSA.

Now if the Job centre decides that they’ll ignore the full-time statement and only look at the hours then I may remain on JSA. JSA requires me to be actively looking for full-time work, even if I am at college, which I am required to provide proof I am looking for it. When offered a job I am also obliged to take it or I would be sanctioned by the benefits agency with them taking financial support away from me.

I can imagine some people will say get a job and do college. The course is called ‘access to social welfare’ and is the equivalent of 3 A-levels in one year not two. It may require only 16 hours class time a week but I am told to match every hour in class with an hour self-study totalling 32 hours. So now add a Job. One that the job centre classes as full-time on top of my 32 week, which is 17 hours. That is 49 hours of work.

I would be no better off financially either; the benefit system allows you to keep the first 5 earned and then take 1 off for every 1 earned. The benefits cover my 70 per week rent also, so in theory I would have to earn 120 a week to pay for my current living expenses of 50 a week for food and utility bills, and then the rent on top. I haven’t even mentioned the cost of council tax.

So is working 49 hours to live on 50-odd really fair? Oh and for those suggesting EMA (Education Maintenance Grant) or ALG (Assembly Learning Grant), I would not be entitled to either as I am too old for EMA at the start of my course and I have a level 3 qualification (my A-level) which means I am not eligible for ALG.

TheSprout got in touch with Leighton Andrews, the Assembly 
Minister for Children, Education and Lifelong Learning and this was his response:

It was disappointing to read about the challenges you’re facing in getting the job you aspire to.

As we emerge from challenging economic times, we must do everything in our power to protect our fragile economic recovery. Tackling youth unemployment in Wales is a key part of this.

Policy relating to employment issues is not devolved to the Welsh Assembly Government; it is the responsibility of the UK Government through the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP). There are however a number of programmes that operate in Wales, through the Department for Work and Pensions and its delivery agent, Jobcentre Plus which can help you.

The Assembly Government does fund an all age impartial information, advice and guidance service through Careers Wales. Careers advice and guidance on routes into social work and any possibilities for funding is available through the Careers Advice helpline on 0800 100 900 run by Careers Wales which provides an all age guidance service.

Careers Information, advice and access to the Learning Choices database is also available online at If you need further support an Adult Guidance officer can be made available at your local Careers office.

I wish you all the best and hope you achieve your goals.

Best Regards

Leighton Andrews AM 
Minister for Children, Education and Lifelong Learning

Comments on original article:

Wow, you’ve experienced so much. It’s crazy how many glitches there seem to be in the system. Good luck to you, you must be a very strong person!

Hi this is meic, we are the information, advice and advocacy providers for children and young people in Wales.

Firstly, it’s fantastic that you have openly shared your experiences with us and given us an insight in to how difficult it can be to get to where we want to be.

It sounds as though there are some obstacles in your way at the moment, however it’s a brilliant thing that you know which career path you want to take and how to go about getting there.

Have you thought about maybe sharing a house/flat with someone so that you can halve the amount you will be paying out each month? Also, it’s says at the top of your article that you are from Cardiff, you could contact Cardiff City Council education department on or 02920 872 938 and see if they can provide you with information on grants and/or other funding schemes.

Although you say you’d prefer not to get a job, it may still be a good idea to look into whether you would be able to get a weekend or evening job, you could then look into whether you qualify for Working Tax Credits. For more information on this or to find out if there’s anything else you could be entitled to, Citizens Advice Bureau are the people to contact.

Here are the contact details for the Cardiff Office: –
First Floor
Castle House
Castle Street
South Glamorgan
CF10 1BS

Adviceline – 0844 477 2020
Reception – 02920 346490

We hope that it all works out for you and that you achieve your goal.

If you would like to talk some more about this, you can contact Meic on 0808 80 23456, text us on 84001 or talk to us via Webchat by going to

Good luck and take care
The Meic Team


Hi. I am going to have a further look into that. I actually contacted your helpline and the advisor i was speaking to didn’t deal with this quiry that well. I believe that the working tax credits won’t be applicable to me in any helpful way but I will definitely look into it further. The reason I don’t move into a house share is that I am currently in council accomodation and I have been advised that it wouldn’t be wise for me to give that up, plus I’ve worked very hard to keep it so far because of being made homeless a second time due to an assault. I am really reluctant to let that go after so much effort I’ve put in to keep it. I’ll respond with a further article to update the situation after I’ve looked even further into it.


Having looked into the Cardiff council student support and they were unable to help, I am not entitled to working tax credits due to my age. please read my updated article.

My Fight For A Career: Continued

Photo Credit: Lonely beach. Playa solitaria by Xos Castro

Do you have a favourite old article that you want to see on the new site? Let us know in the comments below or drop us a message.

Related articles and info:

Work & Training

Get involved:

Want to reach thousands of young Cardiffians? Submit your news here or register to become a contributor.

*Want to become a reviewer? Join the Sprout Editorial Group on Facebook or email

Click here for the next Sprout Editorial Group meeting.

Sprout Editorial Group Banner

Comment below:

It’s free and quick to comment below but we recommend signing up with your email or as a guest to keep usernames Sprouty and anonymous (and never post personal details!).

If you want more info on staying safe online, check out our online safety section.

Have your say

Cyber Essentials Logo

Funding Partners

families first
cardiff partnership
promo cymru